Do you start CPR if there is a pulse?
In this article7 sections
You should not start CPR if the person has a pulse. CPR is intended for individuals who are unresponsive and not breathing normally, indicating a lack of effective circulation. If a pulse is present, the primary issue is likely not cardiac arrest, and chest compressions could cause harm.
When to Begin CPR: A Crucial Distinction
Understanding when to initiate cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is vital for effective emergency response. The core principle guiding CPR is to provide artificial circulation and breathing for someone whose heart has stopped beating effectively or who has stopped breathing. This life-saving intervention is reserved for specific circumstances to ensure it is both necessary and beneficial.
What is a Pulse and Why Does it Matter?
A pulse is the rhythmic throbbing of arteries as blood is propelled through them by the heart. It’s a key indicator that the heart is beating and circulating blood. When assessing an unresponsive person, checking for a pulse is a critical step.
If you can feel a pulse, it generally means the heart is still functioning to some degree. In such cases, the immediate need is not for chest compressions, which are designed to mimic a heartbeat. Instead, the focus shifts to addressing other potential issues that might be causing unresponsiveness or breathing difficulties.
Recognizing the Signs of Cardiac Arrest
Cardiac arrest occurs when the heart suddenly stops beating effectively. This is a life-threatening emergency. The most common signs include:
- Sudden collapse
- Unresponsiveness (not responding to shouting or shaking)
- Absence of normal breathing (no breathing or only gasping)
It’s important to note that gasping can sometimes be mistaken for normal breathing. If someone is gasping irregularly and is unresponsive, it’s a strong indicator of cardiac arrest.
The "Check, Call, Compress" Protocol
Emergency medical services (EMS) often follow a simplified protocol for bystanders. This is commonly known as "Check, Call, Compress."
-
Check: First, check the person for responsiveness. Tap their shoulder firmly and shout, "Are you okay?" Next, check for breathing and a pulse simultaneously. Look for chest rise and fall, listen for breath sounds, and feel for a pulse at the carotid artery in the neck. This check should take no more than 10 seconds.
-
Call: If the person is unresponsive and not breathing normally (or only gasping), call emergency services immediately. If others are present, designate one person to call while another begins CPR.
-
Compress: If there is no pulse and no normal breathing, begin chest compressions. Push hard and fast in the center of the chest.
Why You Shouldn’t Do CPR with a Pulse
Performing chest compressions on someone who has a pulse can be detrimental. The heart is already generating some blood flow, and forceful compressions could potentially disrupt its rhythm or cause further injury. It’s like trying to restart a car engine that’s already running.
Instead, if a pulse is present but the person is unresponsive and not breathing normally, the priority is to ensure they receive advanced medical care quickly. This might involve rescue breaths if you are trained and comfortable doing so, or simply keeping the airway open while waiting for professional help.
When Rescue Breathing is Appropriate
For trained individuals, rescue breathing might be considered if a pulse is present but the person is not breathing normally. This is part of the traditional CPR guidelines, though current recommendations often emphasize compression-only CPR for untrained bystanders due to its simplicity and effectiveness.
If you are trained in CPR and have confirmed a pulse but no normal breathing, you can administer rescue breaths. This involves tilting the head back, lifting the chin, and giving two breaths, each lasting about one second, while watching for chest rise. After administering breaths, you would reassess for a pulse and breathing.
However, for the general public, the most critical action when faced with an unresponsive, non-breathing individual is to call for professional help and begin chest compressions if no pulse is detected.
Key Differences: Pulse vs. No Pulse Scenarios
To clarify the decision-making process, consider these scenarios:
| Scenario | Action to Take